Is It Time to Replace Your Toilet? 5 Signs to Watch For

Your toilet is one of the most frequently used fixtures in your home, but it's easy to take it for granted until something goes wrong. Over time, wear and tear can cause a variety of problems that signal it's time for a replacement. Whether you’re dealing with constant clogs or rising water bills, knowing the signs of a failing toilet can save you time, money, and frustration. Below, we highlight the top five signs it might be time to call in the professionals and invest in a new toilet.

1. Constant Clogs or Poor Flushing Power

If you find yourself reaching for the plunger more often than you'd like, your toilet might not be functioning efficiently. Older toilets, especially those made before 1994, use more water and often lack the flushing power of modern, high-efficiency models. Consistent clogging is not just annoying; it’s also a sign that your toilet may no longer be performing as it should.

2. Cracks in the Tank or Bowl

Porcelain may be tough, but it’s not invincible. Cracks in the bowl or tank can start as tiny hairlines but may grow over time, leading to leaks and water damage. Even if the toilet still functions, any visible crack is a ticking time bomb. Don't wait until you have a full-blown leak on your hands before taking action.

3. Water Around the Base

Finding water pooling around the base of your toilet is never a good sign. It could be something as simple as a worn-out wax seal or as serious as a crack in the toilet itself. Either way, it's a problem that requires attention. Ignoring it could lead to water damage and mold growth, especially on wood flooring and subflooring.

4. Rising Water Bills

Toilets that run constantly or leak silently can waste a surprising amount of water. Even a small internal leak can lead to hundreds of gallons of wasted water each month. If your water bill has been creeping upward and you can't find the source, your toilet could be the culprit. Replacing it with a newer, water-efficient model could lead to significant savings.

5. It’s Just Outdated

Sometimes, the best reason to replace a toilet is simply that it's old, worn, and out of style. If your toilet is stained, hard to clean, or doesn't match your updated bathroom décor, it might be time to upgrade. Newer models not only offer better performance but also improve the overall look of your bathroom.

So how do you know when it's time to stop repairing and start replacing? Here are five clear signs your toilet may be ready for retirement:

• Frequent Repairs: If you’re constantly fixing flush valves, flappers, or fill valves, the cost can add up quickly.
• Age: Toilets older than 20 years are often less efficient and more prone to problems.
• Surface Damage: Cracks, scratches, and stains can make your toilet difficult to clean and unsightly.
• Wobbling: A toilet that shifts or wobbles can indicate floor damage or a faulty installation.
• Inefficiency: Older toilets can use up to 6 gallons per flush, while modern models use 1.6 gallons or less.

If you’ve noticed one or more of these issues, it’s probably time to stop patching things up and invest in a new toilet that works reliably and efficiently.

Ready for a toilet upgrade? Call our experienced plumbers today for professional installation and honest recommendations.

Replacing your toilet might not be the most glamorous home improvement, but it can make a big difference in your comfort, water usage, and bathroom aesthetics. Don’t wait until a small issue turns into a major headache. Let our skilled plumbers help you choose and install the right toilet for your home.